The Best Arguments for Reasonable Term Limits

 The Best Arguments for Reasonable Term Limits

Similar to presidents and some governors, legislators should be subject to term limits. Most experts agree that a term limit shouldn’t be too short or too long. If we make term limits too short, like 12 years, then we fall victim to limiting the policy knowledge of politicians and kicking out politicians once they have effectively learned the in’s and out’s of the government. For Congress, we propose 16 years. Once your time is up in one body, you can move to the other. With a term limit of 16 years, 87 House Representatives and 21 Senators would need to retire. Let’s explain the benefits of such a policy.

The average age of Members of the House at the beginning of the 116th Congress was 57.6years; of Senators, 62.9years.

Congressional Research Service, 2020

Term Limits Lessen Incumbent Advantage

Elections are not term limits. If this were true, many more politicians would be voted out of their position. Compare these two statistics: The modern congressional approval rating is 35% while the modern incumbent win percentage remained at or above 90%.

While we concede that incumbent advantage is not nearly as strong as it used to be, through gerrymandering, consistent donor lists, PAC money, franking privilege, and name recognition, incumbents ultimately have an easier time getting reelected.

Term Limits Infuses New Ideas and People

Unlike the judicial branch, legislators should respond to the passions of the people because they are supposed to represent those very people. In the 116th Congress, only 23% are racial or ethnic minorities. This is compared to a little under 40% of all Americans. The average age of a House member was 57.6 years; for Senators, it was 62.9 years. Some believe that by enforcing term limits, we can diversify a legislative branch to represent America better.

The youngest Representative in the 116th Congress, and the youngest woman ever to serve in Congress, is Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), born October 13, 1989, who was 29 at the beginning of the 116th Congress. The oldest Representative is Don Young (R-AK), born June 9, 1933, who was 85.

Congressional Research Service, 2020

Term Limits Make Politicians Less Election Focused

Some believe that term limits will help politicians be less focused on elections, or at least less politicians in a given Congress since at any given time. There will be a number of senators and representatives who will soon retire. This can have advantages. Politicians will be less partisan and more willing to compromise. They may also be willing to against powerful and rich special interests (that is, of course, assuming that lobbying laws are tightened. Supporters also contend that politicians who are less focused on winning elections will have more time to craft meaningful legislation.

Term Limits Reduce the Effects of Seniority

When people talk about seniority, they usually talk about the reigns of Senator Daniel Inouye (D-Hawaii) and Senator Daniel Akaka (D-Hawaii). Both were pretty veteran politicians by the time they retired from Congress; but what’s more is that their seniority helped gain massive political ‘clout’ for the small Hawaii. Sen. Inouye was 88 at the time of retirement and served 8 terms—a total of 49 years. Sen. Akaka was 89 at the time of retirement and served 3 terms—a total of 22 years due to special elections. Some argue that by limiting the number of terms politicians can serve, it ensures that this power differential between states cannot occur.

Elections Term Limits Are a Popular Policy Proposal

A majority of Americans consistently poll as saying that they want term limits for members of Congress. If this helps to restore a bit of confidence back in the government and back into Congress (which suffers from low approval polling). then we should think about passing term limits legislation—along with other transparency, anti-corruption, and voting rights legislation.

Facebook Comments
Avatar

WIP Democracy

Work in Progress Democracy aims to increase awareness of the issues that affect Americans and provide them with the tools they need to make their voices heard. Follow on Instagram @wipdemocracy

Join the Policybae community!



Sign up for our newsletter for updates sent directly to your inbox.